Toronto’s housing downturn is not being felt equally across the region, with many neighbourhoods still seeing the prices of detached houses climb even while the average price falls across the Greater Toronto Area.
A new report by realty firm Re/Max Integra shows that 40 per cent of 65 districts within the Toronto Real Estate Board recorded detached house price increases in the quarter ended June 30 compared with the first quarter of 2017, including almost half of all the districts in the 905 region surrounding the city of Toronto.
The data suggest the GTA is facing an uneven downturn in house prices that is not being felt to the same extent in some hot neighbourhoods or in certain areas with generally lower prices that remain attractive to first-time buyers.
Tool: Look up home price trends in your neighbourhood
The numbers also support predictions that Toronto’s recent downturn in house prices may reverse course later this year.
Canada Mortgage and Housing Corp. is already anticipating a shift in the Toronto housing market, according to Dana Senagama, a principal market analyst for Toronto. She said the sales downturn in response to new housing measures announced by the Ontario government in late April already seems overblown in light of the region’s economic fundamentals.
“The response we were seeing in the Toronto market seems almost emotional and almost a knee-jerk reaction to some of the changes, which suggests that these impacts will be short-lived if all other fundamentals remain intact,” Ms. Senagama told reporters Wednesday as CMHC released its quarterly housing assessment for Canadian markets.
CMHC chief economist Bob Dugan told reporters that strong job creation and income growth in Toronto favour the housing market. He expects price growth to resume in the city.
House prices in the GTA rose 29 per cent in the first quarter of 2017 but slid in May and June after the Ontario government announced new policy measures, including a 15-per-cent foreign-buyers tax. The number of homes sold in June fell 37 per cent compared with the same month last year, while the average price for all types of homes across the GTA was down almost 14 per cent in June from the peak in April. Prices of detached houses dropped 12.4 per cent on average between the first and second quarters.
But many neighbourhoods and GTA communities have so far bucked the trend. For example, the township of Brock, northeast of Toronto, saw prices of detached houses climb 11.7 per cent in the second quarter, to an average of $562,711. Prices in Caledon rose 8.6 per cent, and Halton Hills saw prices climb 7.8 per cent, the Re/Max Integra report said.
In the city of Toronto, the Toronto Real Estate Board district known as C02, which stretches north of Bloor Street between Yonge and Dufferin streets and includes the Annex neighbourhood, saw detached house prices rise 28 per cent in the second quarter. Re/Max said the price increase was an anomaly as a result of more sales at the higher end of the market in the neighbourhood.
Prices in E01, which is east of the downtown and includes the Riverdale and Greenwood-Coxwell neighbourhoods, climbed 7.6 per cent in the second quarter, while prices in the western Toronto W02 neighbourhood, which runs north of Bloor from Dufferin Street to the Humber River, rose 6.9 per cent.
Christopher Alexander, Re/Max regional director for the Ontario-Atlantic region, said it is “quite remarkable” that prices in some neighbourhoods still climbed beyond the “record-smashing” increases in the first quarter.
Mr. Alexander said the vast majority of markets in the 905 region that recorded increases had average prices under $1-million, which suggests buyers were favouring less-expensive neighbourhoods. In Toronto, however, price increases varied more depending on the volume of new listings and the number of detached houses available for sale in the quarter.
“Some neighbourhoods had such a surge in listing inventory, especially after the government introduced the Fair Housing Plan, so there was a lot to choose from,” he said. “But other neighbourhoods didn’t really get the surge that people were looking for.”
Prices fell most sharply in the central downtown neighbourhood known as C09, which runs north of Bloor between Yonge and the Don Valley, dropping 21.6 per cent in the second quarter. Prices in the C01 district, in the heart of the downtown core north of Lake Ontario between Yonge and Dufferin, dropped 19.7 per cent in the second quarter.
Detached house prices dropped 7.75 per cent in Newmarket and 6 per cent in Vaughan in the second quarter.
Mr. Alexander predicted the next quarter, from July to September, will likely still remain soft because sales are typically weak over summer months, but he believes the GTA market will see more strength in the fourth quarter.
“I think people are going to be ready to buy again, especially if the government announces another [interest] rate hike. I think we’ll see a lot of people jump in,” he said.
DISTRICT AVG. PRICE (Q1 2017) AVG. PRICE (Q2 2017) % CHANGE
C01 $2,039,795 $1,637,293 -19.73%
C02 $2,121,994 $2,715,140 27.95%
C03 $2,485,156 $2,180,007 -12.28%
C04 $2,314,906 $2,441,300 5.46%
C06 $1,695,020 $1,518,812 -10.40%
C07 $1,991,873 $1,959,490 -1.63%
C08 $1,812,000 $1,778,785 -1.83%
C09 $4,249,438 $3,331,250 -21.61%
C10 $1,963,808 $1,913,103 -2.58%
C11 $2,162,543 $2,042,770 -5.54%
C12 $4,183,675 $4,237,132 1.28%
C13 $2,282,801 $2,294,390 0.51%
C14 $2,663,544 $2,579,737 -3.15%
C15 $2,097,757 $2,104,105 0.30%
E01 $1,206,786 $1,298,439 7.59%
E02 $1,505,341 $1,375,293 -8.64%
E03 $1,122,166 $1,048,539 -6.56%
E04 $869,115 $839,646 -3.39%
E05 $1,277,114 $1,147,935 -10.11%
E06 $974,520 $1,009,100 3.55%
E07 $1,114,033 $1,106,574 -0.67%
E08 $1,049,760 $1,014,293 -3.38%
E09 $851,022 $812,394 -4.54%
E10 $991,862 $1,013,207 2.15%
E11 $820,017 $780,578 -4.81%
W01 $1,635,022 $1,725,435 5.53%
W02 $1,300,518 $1,390,342 6.91%
W03 $811,812 $794,200 -2.17%
W04 $1,012,305 $935,246 -7.61%
W05 $971,269 $894,478 -7.91%
W06 $1,036,428 $950,680 -8.27%
W07 $1,362,504 $1,311,176 -3.77%
W08 $1,538,276 $1,501,611 -2.38%
W09 $1,026,757 $1,050,640 2.33%
W10 $758,302 $773,028 1.94%
JANET MCFARLAND – REAL ESTATE REPORTER
The Globe and Mail
Published Thursday, Jul. 27, 2017